Cutting-Edge Technology · The frontier, in progress

Cutting-Edge Technology

Quantum processors, gene editing, fusion experiments and machine learning: the technologies still being invented, and the people patient enough to make them work. Wear the frontier on button-ups and socks, with a computer science tie to match.

Video: NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center

Why it matters

For people who read preprints before breakfast

We can only see a short distance ahead, but we can see plenty there that needs to be done.Alan Turing, Computing Machinery and Intelligence, 1950

The cutting edge is where a technology works in one lab, on a good day, and nobody yet knows what it will become. In 2012 the groups of Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier showed that CRISPR-Cas9 could be programmed to cut DNA at a chosen sequence; eight years later they shared the Nobel Prize in Chemistry. On 5 December 2022 the National Ignition Facility released 3.15 megajoules of fusion energy after its lasers delivered 2.05 megajoules to the target. The lasers themselves drew far more from the grid, which is exactly the next problem.

Working there means reading preprints the morning they appear, then waiting months to see whether anyone can reproduce them. It means clean rooms, cryostats and GPU clusters booked around the clock; demos that worked once and now have to work every time; and the long, unglamorous climb from proof of principle to something a factory can build. Practitioners learn to separate a result from its press release, to love a good error bar, and to keep a straight face when someone asks how many years away it is.

BELOW THRESHOLD

Hold a qubit, cool it, correct it, send it.

Below threshold is the quantum-hardware milestone: physical errors rare enough that a bigger code makes the logical qubit better, not worse. The surface code stores one logical qubit in a square lattice of d² data qubits watched by d² − 1 measure qubits, each check a product of Pauli operators on its neighbors. At distance 5 that is 25 data qubits and 24 checks, and any two errors are corrected; below a threshold near 1 %, every step up in distance makes the logical qubit better still.

Superconducting qubits need a dilution refrigerator. Below 0.87 K a mixture of helium-3 and helium-4 separates, and pumping helium-3 across the phase boundary cools continuously to 5–10 mK, where thermal energy sits 24 times below a 5 GHz qubit. Atom qubits are held in optical tweezers, the single-beam trap of 1986, now built by the thousand. And the 1984 key-distribution protocol sends single photons polarized in two bases: an eavesdropper who intercepts and resends leaves an error rate of one in four.

  • The Surface CodeA square plaque in enamel and gold: 25 gold studs, 16 square and 8 half-round tiles in cobalt blue and terracotta, 24 silver studs.
  • The Dilution RefrigeratorThe gold-plated inner stages: five plates, each smaller than the one above, silver cables and a coiled heat exchanger.
  • Optical TweezersA green beam narrowing out of a microscope objective into a water cell, one bright bead held just past the focus.
  • Quantum Key DistributionFour wire-grid polarizers in brass rims: wires vertical and horizontal for one basis, on the two diagonals for the other.
Tell me when it’s ready

Leave your email and we’ll write the day it’s ready.

EVERYTHING ABSORBS

Below 100 nm there is no glass and no air: only vacuum, mirrors and a few clever tricks.

The first law of short-wavelength light is that every material absorbs it. Below about 100 nm there is no transparent glass and no air to work in, so the sources must be gases, plasmas or electron beams, and the optics must be multilayer mirrors or diffraction. An intense infrared pulse can pull an electron from an atom and drive it back, and the photon it emits on recombining reaches at most Iₚ + 3.17 Uₚ: the plateau and cutoff of high-harmonic generation, odd harmonics only, each burst a few hundred attoseconds long.

Chips are printed with 13.5 nm light, 91.8 eV a photon, made by heating tin droplets into a plasma and gathered by a molybdenum–silicon multilayer mirror. An undulator, a row of alternating magnets, makes relativistic electrons wiggle and shine at λ = λᵤ(1 + K²/2)/2γ²; the first hard X-ray free-electron laser lased in 2009. And a zone plate focuses X-rays by diffraction, its ring edges at rₙ = √(nλf), every zone the same area and the finest setting the resolution.

  • High-Harmonic GenerationA phosphor screen in a steel flange with nine green lines, harmonics 11 to 27 as a flat-field grating spreads them: plateau, then cutoff.
  • Tin-Plasma EUVFour mirror-bright tin droplets falling toward the focus of a concave collector mirror, one white-violet spark at the focus.
  • The UndulatorSixteen magnet blocks, red and blue, seen from above, and a gold wire for the electron’s path, turning over every block’s center.
  • The Zone PlateA gold Fresnel zone plate of twelve equal-area zones on an amber membrane, set in a polished silicon chip.
Tell me when it’s ready

Leave your email and we’ll write the day it’s ready.

SIXTH DECIMAL

Measure the next decimal place and new physics appears.

Precision measurement advances one decimal place at a time, and each new place has a way of turning up new physics. An optical lattice clock holds thousands of strontium atoms in a standing wave of light at the magic wavelength, 813.4 nm, where the trap shifts both clock states equally and so leaves the ticking untouched. A frequency comb counts those optical ticks: its lines sit at fₙ = n frep + fceo, two radio frequencies that any counter can read.

Since 20 May 2019 the kilogram has been defined by fixing Planck’s constant, and one way to realize it counts atoms: a sphere of silicon-28 about 94 mm across, measured by laser and X-ray interferometry, holds 2.15 × 10²⁵ of them. And the nitrogen-vacancy center turns one electron spin in diamond into a sensor read by light: green pumps it, red reads it out, and a magnetic field splits its 2.87 GHz resonance by 56.1 MHz per millitesla.

  • The Optical Lattice ClockA clear glass vacuum cell, a small violet-blue strontium cloud held on one thin red lattice beam.
  • The Frequency CombA glass light sculpture of five identical pulses, the carrier slipping a quarter cycle from each to the next.
  • The Silicon SphereOne mirror-polished sphere of silicon-28, dark gray, reflecting only the studio lights.
  • The NV CenterA pale pink square diamond plate; a green beam crosses it and glows deep red-orange inside.
Tell me when it’s ready

Leave your email and we’ll write the day it’s ready.

Socks mix and match across every field: three pairs for $69, and two ship free in the U.S.

Crew socks · One size

Crew socks

A field of your own, from cuff to toe.

  • The pattern
  • The previewA studio mockup; photos of the finished pair are on the way.
Shop now · Regular price $26 Sale price $23.40

Leave your email and we’ll write the day this pair is ready.

Necktie · 3.5 in wide

Subject ties

A formal introduction to your field.

  • The color
  • The previewStudio render of the tie. Zoom shows the print up close.
Shop now · Regular price $36 Sale price $32.40

Leave your email and we’ll write the day this tie is ready.

The science on the shirt

What you’re wearing

Every object on the shirts, and the science behind it.

The Surface Code

BELOW THRESHOLD

The Surface Code

d = 5: 25 data, 24 checks

The surface code stores one logical qubit in a square lattice of d² data qubits watched by d² − 1 measure qubits. Each check measures X or Z on its neighbors; X and Z checks share zero or two qubits, so all of them commute. At d = 5 that is 25 data qubits and 24 checks, and no logical error is shorter than 5: any two errors are corrected.

The Dilution Refrigerator

BELOW THRESHOLD

The Dilution Refrigerator

proposed 1951, built 1965

Below 0.87 K a helium-3/helium-4 mixture separates, and even at absolute zero about 6.6 % helium-3 stays dissolved. Pumping helium-3 from the dilute phase draws more across the boundary, and the crossing absorbs heat as evaporation does, continuously, at 5–10 mK. Heinz London proposed it in 1951; the first one ran in Leiden in 1965.

Optical Tweezers

BELOW THRESHOLD

Optical Tweezers

first single-beam trap, 1986

A tightly focused laser beam pulls a transparent bead toward its focus, because the light it refracts changes momentum; scattering pushes it along the beam, so the bead settles just past the focus. The forces are piconewtons. Ashkin’s group demonstrated the single-beam trap in 1986; arrays of the same traps now hold single atoms as qubits.

Quantum Key Distribution

BELOW THRESHOLD

Quantum Key Distribution

intercept-resend: 25 % errors

In the 1984 protocol Alice sends single photons polarized at 0°, 90°, 45° or 135°; Bob measures each in a random basis, and they keep the bits where the bases matched. An eavesdropper who intercepts and resends guesses the wrong basis half the time and then randomizes Bob’s result: a 25 % error rate. Below 11 % errors a secret key survives.

High-Harmonic Generation

EVERYTHING ABSORBS

High-Harmonic Generation

cutoff at Iₚ + 3.17 Uₚ

An intense infrared pulse lets an electron tunnel out of an atom, swings it away and drives it back; recombining, it emits one photon carrying the ionization energy plus the energy it gained, at most 3.17 Uₚ. A burst every half cycle makes odd harmonics only, 3.10 eV apart at 800 nm, each burst a few hundred attoseconds long (Corkum 1993).

Tin-Plasma EUV

EVERYTHING ABSORBS

Tin-Plasma EUV

13.5 nm: 91.8 eV a photon

Chips are printed with 13.5 nm light, photons of 91.8 eV that everything absorbs, air included. Molten tin droplets about 30 µm across are flattened by a laser prepulse and heated into a plasma whose tin ions emit in a narrow band at 13.5 nm; a concave mirror of 40 to 60 molybdenum–silicon bilayers, 6.97 nm each, gathers it.

The Undulator

EVERYTHING ABSORBS

The Undulator

λ = λᵤ(1 + K²/2)/2γ²

A row of magnets of period λᵤ makes a relativistic electron wiggle. In its own frame the array is contracted by γ, and the light it emits is Doppler-shifted forward, so on axis λ = λᵤ(1 + K²/2)/2γ². A 3.0 cm period at 1.25 T gives K = 3.50; 0.15 nm X-rays then need 13.6 GeV electrons. The first hard X-ray free-electron laser lased in 2009.

The Zone Plate

EVERYTHING ABSORBS

The Zone Plate

rₙ = √(nλf)

No lens is clear below about 30 nm, so X-ray microscopes focus by diffraction. A zone plate’s ring edges sit where the path to the focus grows by half a wavelength each time, rₙ ≈ √(nλf), so every zone has the same area and the rings thin outward; the finest sets the resolution, 1.22 Δr. In the water window it can image a whole cell in its own water.

The Optical Lattice Clock

SIXTH DECIMAL

The Optical Lattice Clock

magic wavelength 813.4 nm

Strontium-87’s clock transition at 698.4 nm has a natural width near a millihertz. Thousands of atoms are held in a standing wave of light, one pancake every 406.7 nm, at the magic wavelength of 813.4 nm, where both clock states shift equally and the trap leaves the transition untouched. Katori proposed it in 2003; the first lattice clock ran in 2005.

The Frequency Comb

SIXTH DECIMAL

The Frequency Comb

fₙ = n fᵣ + f₀

A mode-locked laser emits identical pulses every 1/frep, but the carrier slips under the envelope from pulse to pulse. Its spectrum is a comb of sharp lines at fₙ = n frep + fceo, both radio frequencies that can be counted. Here the carrier slips a quarter cycle per pulse, so fceo = frep/4 and every fourth pulse repeats.

The Silicon Sphere

SIXTH DECIMAL

The Silicon Sphere

1 kg ²⁸Si: 2.15 × 10²⁵ atoms

Since 20 May 2019 the kilogram has been defined by fixing Planck’s constant, and the mole by fixing Avogadro’s number. A sphere of silicon enriched in ²⁸Si realizes both: its diameter by laser interferometry, its lattice spacing by X-ray interferometry, N_A = 8VM/(a³m). A 1 kg sphere is 93.7 mm across and holds 2.15 × 10²⁵ atoms.

The NV Center

SIXTH DECIMAL

The NV Center

2.87 GHz, read out in red

A nitrogen atom beside a missing carbon in diamond makes a spin-1 defect with a 2.87 GHz splitting. Green light pumps it into its m = 0 state; the other states glow about 30 % dimmer in red, so sweeping microwaves through 2.87 GHz makes the red light dip: one spin, read optically at room temperature. A field splits the dip by 56.1 MHz per millitesla.

The big ideas

What people in cutting-edge technology carry around

CRISPR-Cas9

A guide RNA leads the Cas9 enzyme to a matching DNA sequence, where it cuts. Gene editing became cheap and programmable.

Quantum Error Correction

Qubits lose their superpositions to noise. Error correction spreads one logical qubit across many physical ones, and catches mistakes without looking directly.

Inertial Confinement Fusion

A fuel capsule is crushed so fast that it fuses before it can fly apart. Inertia, not magnets, holds the plasma.

The Transformer Architecture

The 2017 neural-network design built on attention (Vaswani et al.), letting each token weigh the others.

Gravitational-Wave Detection

LIGO’s four-kilometer arms caught two black holes merging on 14 September 2015, by measuring changes far smaller than a proton.

Perovskite Solar Cells

Crystals that can be deposited from solution; Kojima and Miyasaka’s first cells of 2009 converted 3.8%.